There is not much better on a hot summer day than a really good ice cream, unless that is, if it is a really good ice cream that you have made yourself.
The first hand-cranked ice cream machine was invented in 1847. Traditionally, making your own ice cream meant a lot of fuss and bother, hard work and mess. Fortunately, nowadays we have some really cool electronic ice cream makers.
All ice cream makers work by simultaneously freezing the ice cream mixture and stirring or churning it to aerate and prevent the formation of ice crystals.
There are three basic types of modern ice cream makers for the home:
> Counter-top machines which use a freezing element (a double walled bowl which contains a solution that freezes below the freezing point of water) which must be pre frozen in your freezer for up to 24 hours before use. When frozen, the bowl is placed in the machine and the ice cream ingredients are added. This system works best if the ingredients are also ice cold. Rotating paddles (sometimes also called dashers) stir the mixture, which slowly freezes; usually in 20 to 30 minutes. The main disadvantage of this type of maker is that to make multiple batches, you will need multiple bowls, which are usually available for purchase separately. The advantage of this type of ice cream maker is lower cost – usually less than $100.
>Ice cream makers that use crushed ice and rock salt. These are usually more or less bucket shaped and traditional looking. There is usually an outer bowl and a smaller inner bowl. The space between the bowls is filled with layers of crushed ice and rock salt. Some claim that this type of maker creates the best ice cream with the best texture, but the drawbacks are that it is a much messier and labor-intensive process.
>Ice cream makers that have the freezing element built-in. This type of machine can usually make a batch of ice cream in 20 – 30 minutes. Disadvantages are high cost, and in many cases, self-freezing machines are larger. Ice cream machines of this type are usually meant to be stationary, as in some cases moving them will disturb the freezing system’s coolant. Some machines should therefore not be used for up to 12 hours after moving. One advantage for this type of device is that multiple batches can be made.
There are a number of brands of ice cream makers available, and each company usually has several models available of different sizes and with different features. Most of these machines can also be used to make frozen yogurt, sorbet, or frozen drinks as well as ice cream. We will review a few of the more popular models:
Cuisinart 1-1/2-Quart Automatic Ice Cream Maker
This model comes in a choice of white or red housing and uses a freezer bowl. Additional freezer bowls are available for about $30. The top is transparent for easy monitoring. Takes about 20 minutes to make 1 – 1 1/2 quarts of ice cream. The interior chamber is nonstick for easier cleaning. Cuisinart provides a 3-year limited warranty on their ice cream makers.
At just under $50, this is an excellent machine to start making your own ice cream and it is very well rated by users. It is relatively quiet, and easy to use.
Cuisinart ICE-40 Flavor Duo Frozen Yogurt-Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker
This model also uses freezer bowls, but has two 1 quart bowls so that you can make two different flavors at the same time. You can also choose to use only one bowl for smaller batches. This maker is also highly rated by users and runs around $75.
Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker
This is a 1 1/2 quart compressor ice cream maker, so there is no freezer bowl, and you can easily make multiple batches for parties, etc. At about $235 it is more expensive than models that use a freezer bowl; but it is one of the lowest price self-freezing ice cream makers. The mixing paddles are made from plastic, and probably will not be as durable as metal; although replacements are readily available should you require them. Also, this machine is fairly noisy. With the exception of these two common complaints this is another highly rated machine.
Cuisinart Supreme Commercial Quality Ice Cream Maker – ICE-50BC
This is similar to the above machine but the parts, with the exception of the lid, are made of metal. This higher quality also comes at a higher price: just under $400.
KitchenAid KICA0WH Ice Cream Maker Attachment
This is a freezer bowl based maker that is designed to fit on KitchenAid stand mixers. It costs around $75 and will make up to 2 quarts in about 30 minutes. Some parts are dishwasher safe, but the freezer bowl must be hand washed. Overall this gets pretty good reviews, but one has to wonder if it would not be better to just get a dedicated ice cream maker for the same price.
Rival F69206-X 6-Quart Electric White Mountain Ice Cream Freezer
Rival’s ice cream makers use crushed ice and rock salt. They have a more traditional look and even hand-cranked models are available. This model makes 6 quarts, and the freezer can and mixing element are dishwasher-safe, though the salt can cause rusting. The tongue and groove solid pine wood bucket is handcrafted.
This type of ice cream maker is a lot more work than the Cuisinart machines, but it could be a “fun for the whole family” type of event if everyone helps layering the crushed ice and salt preparatory to making the actual ice cream. If this is the kind of experience you are looking for then this is probably the best machine for you! Although some of the lower priced Rival ice cream makers don’t get great reviews, this one, which runs about $179 does. These makers are also noisy, and the wooden bucket can leak (this is probably more likely the drier your climate), so you may need to place it in a tray or tub.
Lello 4070 Gelato Junior
This machine comes with an on-board freezing system, a removable bowl for easier cleaning, and makes one quart in about 30 minutes. It weighs in at 31 lbs. and there is a one-year limited warranty. The Gelato Junior is relatively quiet and gets very good reviews. A couple of complaints are that the ingredient slot is small, and the timer doesn’t turn the machine off – it just alerts you to the fact that you need to turn it off – so this is not a set and forget maker. Also the instruction manual could be better written. At around $195 this is a very reasonably price machine, and is perhaps a better choice than the Cuisinart ICE-50BC if you want a quieter machine and if the smaller capacity works for you.
Lello 4090 Gelato Pro Quart Ice Cream Maker
This model takes about 45 minutes to make 2 quarts of ice cream, so it has twice the capacity of the Gelato Junior. It also has the removable bowl and features an auto shut off timer. The price is about $399, and this maker also gets good reviews by users.
Lello 4080 Musso Lussino 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker, Stainless
If you want the best you have to pay for it! At about $699 this is one of the most expensive ice cream makers designed for home use. The housing, bowl and paddles are all made of stainless steel. Makes 1 1/2 quarts in about 30 minutes. Completely automatic: pour in your ingredients and press two buttons. Built-in freezing system so no freezer bowls to mess with. This device gets very good reviews by users and comes with a one year warranty. One drawback is that the bowl is not removable; so while being stainless makes it easier to clean, you have to clean it in the machine. You probably would want to have a permanent place in your kitchen for this maker, as at 38 pounds it is a little too heavy to be moving in and out of cabinets. It does have a very nice appearance, and will compliment most kitchens.
One thing to consider before buying is that Cuisinart has a reputation for very good customer service; so if you are unlucky enough to purchase a machine that needs warranty work (and Cuisinart’s warranty is longer), you may have a less frustrating experience getting it taken care of if you choose one of their devices.
When you make your own ice cream, remember that the product as it comes out of the machine is in many cases softer than store-bought ice cream. This is especially true of makers that use a freezer bowl. You will probably need to place your fresh ice cream in the freezer for a while to harden before serving.
It is better to mix your ice cream base the night before you intend to use it. This allows the flavors to blend, and your mixture will be cold. Cold ice cream mix means that the ice cream will freeze quicker and also helps to prevent ice crystals.
Many people prefer custard-based ice creams that include egg yolks. Custard-based ice creams are richer, smoother and creamier.
If your machine has a large uncovered opening for adding ingredients, you may achieve better results by covering it with a clean kitchen towel to help prevent cold loss while making your frozen masterpieces.
Finally, you will probably want more recipes than will come with your new gadget, so we have a couple of excellent ice cream recipe books to recommend: Ben & Jerry’s Homemade Ice Cream & Dessert Book
and The Best Ice Cream Maker Cookbook Ever
.